If your ideal weekend involves a full tank of gas, good company, and a whole lot of pizza, welcome to the club. There's no better way to explore the Bay Area than by following the scent of bubbling cheese, crisp crusts, and freshly baked pizza.
Whether you're in it for the love of food or just looking for an excuse to hit the road, this tour across San Rafael, Redwood Shores, and San Mateo is your guide to some of the Bay Area’s most-loved pizza stops.
We're making three stops across the Bay Area: San Rafael, Redwood Shores, and San Mateo, where each Amici's East Coast Pizzeria location brings its own personality while delivering the same familiar favorites. Think of this as your delicious guide to finding the best slices the Bay Area has to offer. Here’s how to plan your Bay Area pizza tour.
First Stop: San Rafael for Relaxed, Flavor-Forward Pizza
Our journey starts in vibrant San Rafael. This Marin County gem combines small-town charm with bold, satisfying flavor. The location here is cozy and relaxed, perfect for families, couples, and Bay Area pizza lovers who appreciate quality without pretense.
The Siciliano here is not messing around. A hearty crust, a crisp base, and bold, balanced flavors. It's the kind of pizza that fills you up in the best way. Not feeling it? Go for the SMOG with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and a generous amount of cheese in every bite.
Amici’s San Rafael's location brings together the best of both worlds: a welcoming neighborhood feel with exceptional food that keeps locals coming back. Whether you're exploring Marin for the day or just craving something delicious, this spot delivers consistently.
Second Stop: Redwood Shores with Easygoing, Group-Friendly Vibes
Next, we head to Amici’s in Redwood Shores, where the waterfront views are almost as good as the pizza. This spot is a favorite for families, professionals on lunch breaks, and anyone who appreciates quality in a relaxed setting. The vibe here is casual, but polished, like catching up with friends on a sunny afternoon.
Now, let's talk pizza. If you've never had the White Clam pizza, this is the perfect place to start. It's a flavor bomb with briny, garlicky goodness that's nothing like your average pie. For veggie lovers, try the one with roasted green peppers and sautéed mushrooms. It's rich, savory, and somehow still feels light.
The Redwood Shores location is perfect if you're with a group or just in the mood for a chill dinner where everyone leaves full and happy. We’ve got gluten-free options that actually taste good, pasta dishes that are consistently satisfying and easy to share, and a relaxed atmosphere that makes you want to stay for one more slice (or three).
Final Stop: San Mateo for Comfort and Community
Last but definitely not least, San Mateo, a city buzzing with energy and excellent taste. It's the kind of place where neighbors become friends, and pizza brings people together.
Walk into Amici's here, and you'll feel it immediately. It's warm, inviting, and smells like fresh pizza from the brick oven. The Motown Meat Lovers pizza is a must-try if you're into bold flavor: layers of pepperoni, sausage, on a Detroit Style crust– just enough spice to keep things exciting. Prefer something simpler? The Margherita keeps things simple with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a bright, well-balanced sauce.
Amici’s in San Mateo feels like your neighborhood hangout. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a few pies for game night, this stop is the familiar, comfort-forward pizza done right. Pro tip: add a Caesar salad to your order. It's fresh, zesty, and plays very well with any pizza.
Three Cities, One Delicious Theme
So, why these three stops? Easy. Each one gives you a different slice of the Bay Area pizza scene, literally and figuratively. San Rafael is charming and full of flavor. Redwood Shores is scenic and satisfying. San Mateo is vibrant and welcoming.
Yet no matter where you go, you'll find the same commitment to fresh ingredients, perfectly crisp crusts, and pizzas that actually taste like something. From crisp crusts to well-balanced toppings, every bite feels familiar and satisfying. It's the kind of consistency that keeps regulars coming back and turns first-timers into fans.
This isn't just about grabbing a bite. It's about finding your new favorite spot (or three). And the best part? You don't have to choose. You can, and should, try them all.
Make It a Pizza Day
Here's your challenge: round up your pizza crew, map out your route, and turn an ordinary day into a delicious adventure. The Bay Area’s pizza culture has been shaped by passionate locals and lifelong pizza lovers, making a tour like this feel especially rewarding.
Start in San Rafael for a satisfying lunch. Cruise over to Redwood Shores for a late afternoon bite with waterfront views. Then hit San Mateo in time for dinner and one final round of cheesy goodness.
Feeling extra ambitious? Make it a weekend plan. Or turn it into a monthly tour and give yourself something to look forward to. If you’re planning a Bay Area food day trip, pairing great pizza with exploring nearby neighborhoods makes the experience even better. There's no wrong way to do it, as long as it involves great pizza and good company.
And if you're thinking, "This sounds amazing, but I live too far from all three," no worries. Amici's has more locations across the Bay Area, each with its own local charm and the same great flavors. So wherever you are, a slice of Amici's is never too far away. Too far to travel? Amici’s delivers throughout the Bay Area so that you can order your pizza from the comfort of your home.
FAQs About Amici’s Bay Area Pizza Locations
Which Amici’s locations are featured in this Bay Area pizza tour?
This tour highlights Amici’s locations in San Rafael, Redwood Shores, and San Mateo, each offering the same core menu with a unique neighborhood feel.
Do all Amici’s locations offer the same pizza styles?
Yes. Each location serves Amici’s signature pizza styles, including classic New York Style thin-crust options and heartier thick, square Detroit-Style pies.
Is Amici’s good for groups or families?
Absolutely. All three locations are well-suited for group dining, casual get-togethers, and family meals.
Can I dine in or order takeout at these locations?
Yes. Amici’s locations offer dine-in, takeout, delivery and catering options depending on location.
Final Thoughts (and Slices)
So there you have it: three towns, three stops, countless memories waiting to happen. Whether you're into thick crust, thin crust, or just delicious crust, there's a spot on this tour with your name on it.
The Bay Area pizza scene is full of options, but Amici's stands out for one simple reason: it cares about doing pizza right. No shortcuts. Just honest, delicious food rooted in Northeast-inspired pizza traditions and a sincere focus on doing things right every time.
Your Bay Area pizza tour is ready to begin. All that's left to do is grab your keys, bring your appetite, and wear stretchy pants, because once you start, stopping won't be easy.
See you on the road, and more importantly, around the Amici’s table.