At Amici’s, we believe pizza night should never be ordinary. Whether you're a firm believer in the power of a traditional cheese slice or you're constantly chasing the next bold flavor combo, our menu is designed to deliver the best of both worlds. From crispy brick-oven classics to daring new signatures, there's a pizza (or five) waiting to become your new favorite.
So, if you’ve ever wondered what makes an Amici’s pizza stand out — or what you should try next —you’re in the right place. Now, let’s dive into the pies that put us on the map and the ones that keep customers coming back for more.
Why Amici’s Pizza is a Cut Above
What sets an Amici’s pizza apart isn’t just what you see. It’s how we make it from crust to finish. Every pizza is baked in our signature brick oven, delivering a crust that’s crispy on the bottom, tender inside, and kissed with just the right amount of char. It’s the kind of texture you only get with serious heat and serious skill.
We also don’t cut corners with our ingredients. We use San Marzano tomatoes, whole milk mozzarella, fresh garlic, fragrant basil, and locally sourced produce wherever possible. Every topping is chosen to complement the next, and every bite is crafted for flavor harmony.
And we get it, everyone has different needs and cravings. That’s why we offer gluten-free crusts, vegan cheese, and an array of topping options to suit all diets and lifestyles. Whether you’re keeping it classic or going full food adventurer, there’s a pizza for you here.
The Classics You Shouldn’t Skip
Some things never go out of style. If you're a fan of time-tested flavors, our classic pizzas are sure to hit the spot.
New York-Style Cheese Pizza
This one’s for the purists. Our New York-style pizza is thin, foldable, and packed with flavor. It starts with our signature tomato sauce, romano, and mozzarella, but its real strength is in the simplicity. Perfect as-is or the perfect base for your favorite toppings.
Margherita
The Margherita is our love letter to the East Coast traditions. Ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, olive oil, and fragrant basil come together in a pie that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. It’s light, clean, and a reminder that sometimes less really is more.
Pepperoni Perfection
Think bubbling cheese, crispy pepperoni edges, and just the right amount of grease (the good kind). It’s comfort food at its finest, elevated by Amici’s attention to detail and our beloved brick oven.
Classic Veggie
Loaded with fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, olives, and more, our veggie pizzas are bright, colorful, and bursting with flavor. Great for vegetarians, or anyone who wants something a little lighter without sacrificing taste.
Amici’s Creative Signatures: Unexpected, Unforgettable
We love a good tradition, but we also love breaking the mold. These signature pies take flavor to the next level.
Milano Pizza (Potatoes on Pizza!)
Yes, we put potatoes on pizza, and you’re going to be obsessed. The Milano features roasted yukon gold potatoes, bacon, slow-roasted garlic, red and green onions, hot red pepper flakes, mozzarella and provolone, for a crispy, herb-forward pie that’s hearty, comforting, and totally unforgettable.
Spicy Pepper Chicken Pizza
For those who like it hot. This white pie layers sliced chicken breast, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, cilantro, oregano, hot red pepper flakes. It’s bold, zesty, and brings the heat in the best way possible.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Sweet meets smoky in this fan favorite. Our BBQ Chicken pizza comes with tangy barbecue chicken, red onions, bacon, and a sprinkle of cilantro. It’s a flavor bomb that’s perfect for those looking to mix things up.
Perfect Pairings: Sides and Sips to Complete the Meal
No great pizza night is complete without a few supporting players. Craving something crunchy? Start with garlic bread or a Caesar salad for that perfect mix of textures. Want to double down on bold flavors? Our BBQ-style or lemon-roasted chicken wings are the perfect companion to any signature pie.
When it comes to drinks, pair your pizza with a sparkling soda, a chilled iced tea, or even a craft beer or glass of wine if you're dining in. And if you have a sweet tooth, round things out with a coffee and one of our signature desserts: New York Style Cheesecake or Chocolate Tuxedo Cake.
Vegan, Vegetarian, and Gluten-Free Picks
We’re all about inclusivity, especially when it tastes this good. Our vegan pies feature dairy-free cheese and plant-based toppings that don’t feel like an afterthought. Our One Step Beyond Pizza is a top pick, and our Artichoke Panzanella Salad makes a perfect pairing.
Need to go gluten-free? Our gluten-free crust is so good, you might not even notice the difference. It holds up under all the toppings and bakes to golden perfection in our brick ovens.
If you’re the creative type (or just picky), you can also go for custom creations and build your own pizza like a pro. Our build-your-own pizza option gives you total control. Start with our classic or gluten-free crust, pick your sauce (red or pesto), add cheese (regular, vegan, or extra), and then pile on your dream toppings.
Pro tip? Mix textures and temperatures. Go with a combo of crispy and creamy — like roasted peppers with goat cheese — or sweet and spicy like pineapple and jalapeño. You might just create the next Amici’s legend.
Find Your Signature Slice
From tried-and-true classics to wild new flavor combos, Amici’s has a signature pizza to match every mood, craving, and personality. Whether you're the kind of person who always orders the Margherita or you're ready to try potatoes on your pie, there’s something on our menu that’ll make your night.
So next time you’re choosing where to grab a slice or planning your ultimate pizza party, remember: at Amici’s, every pizza tells a story. Which one will you try next?