Redwood City is known for sunshine, tech hustle, and a community that knows how to eat well. But let’s be real, when the question is “what’s for dinner?”, the answer is almost always pizza. Pizza in Redwood City isn’t just food; it’s the mood.
And if you’re looking for the best pizza Redwood City has to offer in 2025 and beyond, there’s only one spot worth talking about: Amici’s. Forget scrolling endlessly through pizza places in Redwood City, CA. We’ve got this ultimate list, and yes, it’s all Amici’s, because that’s where the magic happens.
Why Amici’s is the Main Character of Redwood City Pizza
Amici’s isn’t just about pizza; it’s about crafting memorable slices. These aren’t your average pies. We’re talking crisp New York-style thin crust baked in real brick ovens, toppings that don’t play around, and flavor combos that feel like they were made for your next Instagram story.
If you’re into bold, share-worthy pizza moments, Amici’s is where you want to be. Whether you’re team classic cheese, all about the meat, or living your best plant-based life, the menu has a craveable vibe for everyone.
So, let’s dive into the official 2025 list of the best pizzas in Redwood City, straight from Amici’s oven to your feed.
The 2025 Pizza Line-Up
When it comes to pizza in Redwood City, California, Amici’s doesn’t just serve slices; it serves experiences. New York pies are baked directly on a blazing-hot brick oven floor (700°F) for that unmistakable crispy, slightly charred bite. Detroit pies are baked in signature steel pans to form the perfect cheesy, crispy edges and corners. Here are the standouts that keep locals coming back:
Detroit Thick Crust
Amici’s Detroit–style thick-crust pizzas are the definition of comfort with a little attitude. Think tall, golden edges, a crispy-cheesy crown, and a soft, airy center that soaks up every drop of sauce. They’re hearty, square-cut pies built for sharing or not; we don’t judge. A few standouts:
Three Cheese Red Top (Vegetarian)
For anyone who believes cheese deserves the spotlight. Mozzarella, provolone, and Romano blend into a gooey harmony on a golden crust that’s equal parts crunchy and chewy. It’s a rich, melty indulgence that feels like pizza’s greatest hits in one bite.Pepperoni Pie
There’s classic, and then there’s Amici’s classic. Tangy tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and pepperoni that crisps up at the edges into little flavor-packed cups. It’s a mic-drop moment on every slice.BBQ Chicken
Sweet meets smoky in this modern favorite. Tender BBQ chicken, red onions, and bacon get layered with mozzarella, then drizzled with BBQ sauce and topped with cilantro. It’s the pizza version of a backyard summer cookout.
Whether you’re sharing with friends or enjoying a solo indulgence, Detroit-style pies bring hearty flavor and crispy perfection to every bite.
New York Thin-Crust
Amici’s New York–style thin-crust pizzas are where tradition meets brick-oven magic. Light, foldable slices with just the right char on the edges, they’re the kind of pizzas that feel just as good on a Tuesday night as they do at a Friday hangout. A few favorites:
New York Cheese
Sometimes, less really is more. Tomato sauce and mozzarella team up for the purest expression of pizza. Crisp on the bottom, gooey on top, this is the slice that proves simplicity can be perfection.Margherita
A fresh and elegant option that feels straight out of an Italian piazza. Juicy tomatoes, fragrant basil, and a drizzle of olive oil bring out bright, garden-fresh flavors. It’s pizza with a touch of sophistication.Boston
A surprise star of the menu. Fried eggplant takes center stage, adding a rich, slightly smoky flavor that pairs beautifully with mozzarella and tomato sauce. It’s hearty, unique, and unlike anything else in Redwood City.
These foldable, brick-oven-baked pies prove that thin crust can deliver bold flavor and satisfying crust every time.
Pizza for Every Kind of Night
Pizza isn’t just food; it’s the soundtrack to your life. Amici’s has a pie for every moment:
Post-class hangout: New York Pepperoni. Affordable, shareable, and always hits.
First date nerves: Margherita. Simple, elegant, and you won’t drip sauce on yourself.
Group game night: Motown Meat Lovers. Big flavors for big crowds.
Spicy challenge with friends: Firehouse Special. Whoever sweats the most has to grab the next round of sodas.
Solo binge-watch session: Three Cheese Red Top. Cozy, cheesy, and unapologetically indulgent.
Sometimes leaving your couch isn’t the vibe. That’s when Amici’s pizza delivery in Redwood City comes to the rescue. Fresh, hot pies land at your door without losing any of that brick-oven magic.
Whether it’s a last-minute study group, a movie night marathon, or just one of those evenings where cooking feels like a horror story, Amici’s delivery has you covered.
Pizza + Sides = The Ultimate Combo
Sometimes pizza needs a wingman. At Amici’s, you don’t just stop at the pies. The menu is stacked with:
Pastas that twirl like a dream
Fresh salads that balance out the cheesy goodness
Italian starters for setting the tone
Sandwiches that hit just as hard as a slice
Desserts that satisfy your sweet tooth
Wash it all down with your drink of choice, and suddenly your pizza night has turned into a full-on feast.
Ready to Make Your 2025 Pizza Bucket List?
Life’s too short for boring food. This year, let Amici’s be the reason you keep saying, “yeah, let’s get pizza.” With options for meat-lovers, veggie fans, spice chasers, and cheese devotees, there’s something here for every craving.
Amici’s is top-rated by locals and featured in Silicon Valley and North Bay Pizza Week events for its innovation, consistency, and quality.
Your only job? Decide which pizza to try first. Pro tip: start with the Pepperoni Pie if you’re a classic fan, Firehouse Special if you’re feeling bold, and Three Cheese Red Top if you’re all about comfort food.
Whichever way you go, Amici’s has your back and your next favorite slice. Visit Amici’s, Redwood Shores today!